Freud's Idea of Rational Action

Freud's idea of rational action is that it is in perpetual tension with emotional and especially sexual desire toward gratification but that a desire for and engagement in both rational action and satisfaction of desire characterizes human experience. However, rational action per se comes about as the individual ego evolves from infancy to adulthood, increasingly experiencing the fact that it and the organism that it inhabits is different from (and alien to) the world that is external to it: "originally the ego includes everything, later it separates off an external world from itself" (Freud 15).

Alienation of the ego from the world arises out of recognition of the separation. The ego encounters conflict even as it seeks satisfaction, or happiness, and as it seeks to accommodate itself to what is other, the world, in hope of experiencing happiness. Freud cites the "dichotomy" of human aims: "man's activity develops in two directions, according as it seeks to realize . . . the one or the other of these aims" (25). Man is pulled toward social interaction to avoid isolation but away from it to avoid inevitable human conflict. Impulse toward rational action is an impulse away from the experience of conflict. Freud connects it to an impulse toward social interaction, which involves "becoming a member of the human community, and with the help of a technique guided by science, going over to the attack against nature and subjecting her to the human will" (27). Another rational

Related Essays

Christian Faith .... so, mankind's experience of the world cannot be rational, and if .... secular existentialist theory, Christian theory includes a sacral idea of the .... Freud, S. (1961 .... (7281 29 )

Edited Freud & Piaget .... stress is ameliorated, "It is on this idea of resistance .... in secondary-process thinking, which is relatively rational, realistic, and .... Freud, S. (April 1910). .... (3485 14 )

The Mind-body Dualism Split .... of one Mary Fields, who corresponded with Freud about a .... in this area is connected to the idea that psychology .... Somatic site(s) of action (Carlson 87) for the .... (4515 18 )

LOGOTHERAPY .... ration" (Perrin 1998, 2). Many find the main idea underlying transcendentalism .... the spiritual with the humanistic and the rational yields the .... Freud, S. (1998). .... (5964 24 )

DETERMINISM VERSUS FREE WILL Introduction The .... other hand, the British monk Pelagius opposed this idea and maintained .... According to Pervin (1980), Freud viewed the human as an .... Sue, S., Sue, S. & Sue, D. (1994 .... (2624 10 )

Emotional Maturity .... one aspect of human experience that "boil[s] up from .... and falls with the religious system" (Freud 230 .... That same idea would help explain the intersection of such .... (2695 11 )

organization ad market protocols, evolved from "the spirit of Christian asceticism" (180). The common element: deliberate renunciation of physical gratification, or what Freud would call sublimation of sexual impulse, for work. Thus sublimation becomes "ascetic Protestantism" (183), i.e., the Protestant Work Ethic. This squares with Weber's focus on social structure as a consequence of rational action. He cites (Protestant) Adam Smith's economic theory, which amounts to a "moral justification of worldly activity" (81), and which famously includes the doctrine of an "invisible hand" of market order and rationality held to be a feature of capitalism. In a footnote Weber (213) also quotes Smith's explanation of general acquiescence in capitalism in terms of "self-love," or the benefits derived by rational participants who exchange what they have of value in the capitalist marketplace. These are not sexual or psychological but material benefits. For the relationship between rational action and self-interest involves formulating the compulsions of individuals in economic rather than spiritual terms, i.e., in terms of cost and benefit instead of good and evil. 4. The principal sense in which both Freud and Weber can claim that thei

Category: Psychology - F