Wrongful Birth Memo

This research paper consists of a Memorandum of Points and Authorities to support a motion by Dr. Well and General Hospital for summary judgment on daughter Helen's claim for wrongful birth and mother-patient Susan's claim for wrongful life.

Child's Cause of Action for Wrongful Birth

The basis for the daughter's cause of action is unclear. If she is alleging that Dr. Well's and General Hospital's negligence were the proximate cause of injury she suffered, such an action will lie, but she must prove that negligence was proximate cause of the injury and the proper cause of action is not one for wrongful birth or life. According to Prosser and Keeton, "the child, if he is born alive, is now permitted in every jurisdiction to maintain an action for the consequences of prenatal injuries, and if he dies of such injuries, action will lie for wrongful death."

Plaintiffs have their causes of action reversed. The Harvard Law Review says that in a "wrongful birth action, the parents of a child suffering from birth defects sue a health care provider;" and "wrongful life is a claim brought by or on behalf of a child with birth defects."

The New Jersey Supreme Court in the case of Procanik v. Cillo, 97 N.J. 339, 478 A. 2d 755 (1984), noted the confusion in terms: "The terms 'wrongful birth' and 'wrongful life' are but shorthand phrases that describe the causes of action of parents and children when medical negligent treatment deprives parents of

Related Essays

PRENATAL DEVELOPMENT AND TESTING Introduction .... 7. Wrongful birth suits should only be permitted with children who are disabled if they are permitted with children who are nondisabled. .... (3936 16 )

Jewish and American Law .... answered are recorded, A law that holds that suicide is wrongful is, necessarily .... be denied by the ending of life--(a) conception, (b) birth, (c) circumcision, (d .... (3390 14 )

SUBSTANCE ABUSE AMONG PREGNANT WOMEN .... blood pressure and result in a stroke in utero shortly after birth, [and] a .... viable fetus as a person for purpose of homicide laws and wrongful death statutes .... (4125 17 )

Legal Aspects of Nursing .... Laws and ethics overlap in areas such as death, dying, birth, abortion, genetics .... A tort is a wrongful act committed which produces harm, unintentional or .... (1527 6 )

Aeschylus' Orestia Trilogy .... the text recalling Clytaemestra's dream that she would give birth to a .... the spellbinding consequences of Orestes' avenging of his father's wrongful death, his .... (1548 6 )

22 C.R. 2d 819 (1993), a California appellate court extended the Turpin doctrine to post-conception negligence and held the health-care providers liable for failing to inform the baby's pregnant mother of the need to take a second blood sample for AFP testing. In 1993, the California Supreme Court voted six to one to re-affirm Gami. In Curlender, there is dicta in the appellate court's opinion to the effect that the child could recover pain and suffering damages. In Turpin, the California Supreme Court "found that general damages were not awardable." The policy reasons behind the California courts' reluctance to find liability where the tests results are conjectural and to limit recoverable damages even where negligence in pre-natal testing is proven are several-fold. (1) In Gami, the appellate court said that "whether it is better to have been born at all than to have been born with even gross deficiencies is a mystery left more properly to philosophers and theologians." Logically, the negligence of the health care provider has caused the birth, not the defect. The California courts have recognized that liability may exist in such cases to the parents, but not to the child, except for medical expenses and the costs

Category: Government - W