Standard Medical Treatment vs Chiropractic Care

The subject of standard medical treatment versus chiropractic care has been a volatile argument for the last several decades. In fact, as early as 1963, the American Medical Association had formed a Committee on Quackery to deal with what it considered to be a major problem with chiropractic care. In 1976, five chiropractors responded to the AMA's dictum by countersuing with an antitrust suit. In 1987, that suit was decided.

A federal district court judge, Susan Getzendanner, found that the AMA was guilty of conspiracy in 'restraint of trade' against the chiropractic profession, that it had unlawfully deprived chiropractors of association with medical doctors, and that by calling them 'unscientific cultists' it had eroded the credibility of the profession. [Further], the Committee on Quackery was disbanded in 1975, but the AMA continued its official anti-chiropractic efforts until 1980 (Shell, 1988, p. 78).

As one might expect, the AMA further pressed the case, which went to a court of appeals that handed down its verdict, once again against the AMA, in the early months of 1990 (Appeals court rules, 1990, p. A12).

This paper will compare and contrast the role of the doctor of chiropractic, the medical doctor, the doctor of osteopathy, and the physical therapist in order to analyze and determine if a dichotomy actually exists between the different approaches to health care. Underlying the central thesis of the paper is the supposition that chiropractic is a viable, ef

Related Essays

Chiropractic Medicine & Spinal Manipulation .... The osteopathic treatment group required significantly less .... used less physical therapy (0.2 percent vs. .... osteopathic manual care and standard medical care have .... (1058 4 )

Health Care vs. Economics Terms .... Quality can be the general standard or grade of something. .... In an economic sense, cost of medical care in the .... spent to produce the service or treatment can also .... (855 3 )

Medical Pratice Guidelines .... Standard medical practice, furthermore, may not necessarily be a .... to express themselves." Medical practice guidelines .... the futility of treatment procedures in .... (4323 17 )

HOMEOPATHY & PAIN Introduction This research pap .... Homeopathy is now being studied at medical schools (Wheeler .... The Kent's Repertory is a standard repertory that .... in many cases, including the treatment of headaches .... (5367 21 )

Treatment of Bulimia .... of cognitive-behavioral group therapy and standard group therapy .... waiting list and receiving no treatment until the .... Medical aspects of the bulimic syndrome and .... (1827 7 )

ences in treatment likewise do so. Nevertheless, one of the most basic ways of characterizing traditional medicine is to look for a specific cause of an affliction, and then treat the symptoms. This, of course, contrasts with chiropractic medicine in that the nervous system, spine, or general holistic view of the patient is not considered as an integral part of the treatment program. One typical stereotype about the medical doctor revolves around the relationship between the patient and the cure, sometimes called the "medical mystique." Like many other societal myths, it is built on a foundation of truth. The medical mystique involves a set of beliefs that most of us share and that strongly influence our actions when we confront medical issues . . . The mystique begins with the existence of disease . . . [and] each time we go to a doctor when we're sick, the conditions for perpetuation the myth of curing are met . . . The medical mystique works to keep the doctor from really leveling with the patient (Glasser & Pelto, 1980, pp. 27-29). Osteopathy, or the medical therapy that emphasizes manipulative techniques for correcting somatic problems thought to cause disease and inhibit recovery, has some similarities to chiropractic

Category: Medical - S