Contrast of Athens with Sparta

To contrast Athens with Sparta is to contrast theories of governance with political style. That is the major lesson to be drawn from Thucydides. The reputation of Athens is that it was cultured and learned, willing to expose itself to other peoples, compared to Sparta's austerity and militarist form of social organization. The Speech of the Corinthians of the Debate at Sparta implicitly valorizes Athens when observing that Lacedaemonian insularity "makes you rather ignorant in foreign affairs" (Thucydides 17). Athens made a project of inserting itself into foreign affairs. Its naval mobility empowered it to extend its conquests to a variety of distant places to engage in wealth-building trade and to absorb cultural lessons from abroad--and collect tribute.

Tribute-paying city-states around the Aegean would be protected from other invaders and would be fully engaged in the trade network of the Delian League. So-called resident aliens (Thucydides 34) were routinely recruited into the Athenian naval forces, providing linkages between subjugated peoples and the mother country. Athens perceived naval power as the ultimate in enrichment and prestige, superior to Sparta's land power. As Pericles explains in the opening phase of the Peloponnesian War:

If they build only an observation post . . . they may damage some of our land by raiding it, and they may take in runaway slaves; but this would not be enough to keep us from sailing to their land and building forts there or retaliat

Related Essays

The Greek City-States of Athens & Sparta .... regards the opposite pole of Athens from a cultural perspective" (Culture, 2003, 1). If we make a comparison and contrast of Athens and Sparta, despite their .... (703 3 )

Works of Ancient Greece .... Sparta, obsessively concerned with producing legions of strong bodies, stands in sharp contrast with Athens, a city-state consistently preoccupied with .... (2974 12 )

Greek Civilization and the West .... Sparta, obsessively concerned with producing legions of strong bodies, stands in sharp contrast with Athens, a city-state consistently preoccupied with .... (2973 12 )

The Histories of Herodutus .... with the opportunity "to give a survey of the chief Greek peoples at that time," in particular presenting the contrast between Athens and Sparta that will .... (3143 13 )

Akhenaton and Pericles .... In Sparta, privacy, luxury, and even comfort were all sacrificed to the mission of training soldiers who would become .... Athens, in contrast, was highly .... (1025 4 )

Category: History - C