State and Power
This is an excerpt from the paper...
Of three versions of the relationship between the state and power, Marx's and Engels' version, Lenin's variation of Marxism, and Weber's theory, none perfectly fits the current state of affairs in the United States. The first Marxist version offers insights into the nature of collusion between capital interests and government. The Leninist version has the least to offer, since it concentrates so heavily on extreme repression. Weber's ideas offer the best vehicle for analyzing the state in America. Weber considered both internal and external pressures on domestic politics and, therefore, covered more ground in assessing the nature of the state's power. Two conceptions of the nature of the state exist in Marxist theory. The first is that proposed by Marx and Engels. Roughly, this view is that the state is, as Engels puts it, "a product of society at a certain stage of development" (103). The state was needed at the capitalist stage of development to manage the conflict between the capital and labor. Class warfare would not result because the state was managing to maintain a state of equilibrium between the classes. Engels believed that public power (the use of force) was a necessary component of the state, but thought this too was temporary. He believed that the state's need for coercion would dissipate as it progressed toward socialism. This was a progressive view, in which the belief in history prevailed. Marx and Engels firmly believed that the state would be t
. . .
US situation perfectly in several respects. The collusion between the state and the Stock Market (the interests of capital in general) describes the current state of affairs in American politics. Both political parties, at all levels, are so dependent on the financial support of corporations and their owners, that it is inevitable that their interests become intertwined. Engels also saw that the mere threat of force was all that was necessary for the state to maintain power. In American society the threat is there but, because the citizens are compliant, it almost never needs to be exercised. Though, it might also be argued, the use of force on the underclass serves as a constant reminder to the proletariat. This use of force, of course, is presented as being in the proletariat's best interests -- protecting them from the underclass. This, of course, increases the proletariat's identification with the state while simultaneously warning of the consequences of not identifying with the state.
In Max Weber's approach to the state, power derives from external relations in order to be used in internal politics. In order to be perceived as legitimate and gain power over their members, states must be perceived as being powerful
. . .
Some common words found in the essay are:
According Weber, Exchange Engels, Marx Weber, Marx Engels, Stock Market, President Bush, Engels Roughly, Republican Congress, Marx's Engels', Lenin Lenin, state's power, physical force, class conflict, marx engels, internal politics, weber's theory, manager class conflict, defeat iraq, imperialist policy, collapse ussr, manager class, balance potential profits, class conflict lenin,
Approximate Word count = 1862
Approximate Pages = 7 (250 words per page)
More Essays on State and Power
|