Capital Punishment Views
This is an excerpt from the paper...
It has been suggested that capital punishment helps to shape society's moral condemnation of serious crimes; murder in particular. In fact, author Steven Goldberg views capital punishment as the worst possible thing society can do to a convicted criminal. Moreover, it is interesting to note that messages are sent that both help and hinder the argument for capital punishment as an effective means to deal with severe crimes.1 As a means of discussing Goldberg's view, this paper will present a brief overview of the way that capital punishment was used in the history of western society. After the overview, we will look at a detailed analysis of Goldberg's argument, paying particular attention to the way Goldberg responds to the evidence for and against the death penalty.From the outset, it appears that capital punishment, although used often, has not done much in the way of promoting regard for human life. From 1930 to 1967, 3,859 people were executed under the rubric of capital punishment in the United States.2 Since 1967, very few have met the same fate 38 states have adopted new sentencing and 1 Steven Goldberg, "On Capital Punishment," Ethics 85 (1974): 6774. 2 Thomas Draper, ed., Capital Punishment, (New York: H.W. Wilson, 1985), 6. punishment standards, and the debate continues to be a national issue. The argument runs deep into the strains of society: how should a democratic society punish those individuals who have chosen to com
. . .
dstill. The 1970s became a vitally important decade in the issue of capital punishment, and focused on a challenge to the Constitution itself. The debate centered on the Eighth Amendment that banned "cruel and unusual punishment" and its relationship to capital punishment in general.12
Thus, the major issues of the 1970s surrounded the manner in which the death penalty was carried out not necessarily on the act itself. The 1980s, with its return to extreme conservative values and attitudes, took a more singular view of the issue. For instance, in Ronald Reagan's 1985 State of the Union Address, he stated, "In keeping with the will of the overwhelming majority of Americans, the death penalty must be imposed when necessary."13 He based this on research from MediaGeneral poll takers and a poll which gave
____________________
11 Lawrence Kohlberg and Donald Effenbein, "Moral Judgments about Capital Punishment: A DevelopmentalPsychological View," in Hugo Adam Bedau and Chester M. Pierce, eds., Capital Punishment in the United States, (New York: AMS Press, 1976), 251.
12 Franklin E. Zimring and Gordon Hawkins, Capital Punishment and the American Agenda, (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986), 501.
13 Dra
. . .
Some common words found in the essay are:
Citadel Press, Zimring Hawkins, Capital Punishment, Court Foes, University Press, HW Wilson, Steven Goldberg, capital punishment, Charles Manson, Basil Blackwell, Middle Ages, death penalty, issue capital punishment, goldberg's view, punishable death, cruel unusual, van den, issue capital, unusual punishment, punishment united, capital punishment united, cruel unusual punishment, moral theory, capital punishment editorial, ams press 1976,
Approximate Word count = 2287
Approximate Pages = 9 (250 words per page)
More Essays on Capital Punishment Views
|