Psychological Aspects of Rheumatic Disease
This is an excerpt from the paper...
Depression, Quality-of-Life, and severity of rheumatic disease were assessed in a sample of elderly patients receiving out-patient services at a large metropolitan general hospital. All patients were volunteers recruited by the investigator using a list (provided by the hospital) of patients between 65 and 80 years of age receiving out-patient services for physician diagnosed conditions of rheumatic disease. Subjects were matched on severity of rheumatic disease. Quality-of-Life was then compared for two depression groups (Low and High). Depression groups were obtained by dividing subjects' scores at the mid-point score and assigning everyone below this score to the Low Depression group and everyone above this score to the High depression group. Quality-of-Life was measured using a researcher-designed instrument developed using feedback from experts in the field and the information contained in the Quality-of-Life literature. The severity of rheumatic disease was measured by having the physicians of each patient rate disease severity along a ten point scale with severity increasing with numerical score value. Depression was assessed using the Beck Depression Inventory, a 21 item standardized instrument designed to provide a quantitative assessment of the intensity of depression. Data was analyzed using the t-test analysis to compare Quality-of-Life scores for the two depression groups. Findings indicated that Quality-of-Life was significantly lower in the
. . .
rument that has been established to be psychometrically sound in a variety of diverse studies (Leahy, 1992). Thus, of the three measures used in the study, the only one in which confidence can be placed as to its reliability and validity is the Beck Depression Inventory.
In addition to the problem concerning the test instrument, the study also has some difficulties in relation to sample subjects. First, age itself can lead to increasing physical debilitation and attendant levels of depression (Skipwith, 1994). Given this, an attempt should have been made to not only match subjects with respect to the variable of severity of disease but also with respect to the age variable. Because of the failure to control for age in this way, it is possible that Quality-of-Life differences were, at least in part, attributable not to differences in depression but to differences in subjects' ages. Indeed, when one considers the level of physical debilitation that can take place across the sample age range--65 to 80--the reasonableness of this speculation is made even more salient.
Further, there is a problem associated with the fact that subjects were volunteers. According to Adair (1973), volunteers are a group with consistently different
. . .
Some common words found in the essay are:
Depression Inventory, Low Depression, Summary Conclusions, Adair Compared, Depression Quality-of-Life, Sue Sue, Beck Measure, Depressed Depressed, Adair JG, rheumatic disease, According Adair, severity rheumatic, severity rheumatic disease, beck depression, complete test, depression inventory, low depression, beck depression inventory, sue sue, test instrument, complete test instrument, standardized instrument, mid-point score, depression low depression, receiving out-patient services,
Approximate Word count = 1462
Approximate Pages = 6 (250 words per page)
More Essays on Psychological Aspects of Rheumatic Disease
|