The Commerce Clause-Federalist No. 51

In looking at the Federalist No. 51 and Article I, Section 8, Clause 3 in the U.S. Constitution, we recognize immediately that there is a duality in American government. This duality encompasses the dilemma of states' rights versus federal rights of the national government. Article I, Section 8, Clause 3 is also known as the "commerce clause", a clause which permits Congress to "regulate Commerce with foreign nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian tribes" (Commerce 1). Yet, the Constitution is constantly open for interpretation by whichever group of judges presides over the nation's highest court. In 1824 the Supreme Court found in Gibbons v. Ogden that a broad definition of interstate commerce was intended by the framers of the Constitution. Yet, this decision did allow for the federal government to exercise control over state commerce if the state was guilty of violating the dormant character of the Commerce Clause, "Where state legislation resembles regulation of interstate commerce, or is discriminatory in effect, the State may have violated the dormant nature of the Commerce Clause which by its mere presence in the Constitution grants exclusive power over regulation to Congress" (Commerce 1). Ever since this time the federal government has been at odds with itself and with the states regarding the regulation of interstate commerce.

During the years before Roosevelt's New Deal, the Court controlle



Related Essays

Division of Powers .... for changes, and for reform: The states are no better or .... infringe on interstate commerce, regulated by the interstate commerce clause of the .... The Federalist, Nos .... (1768 7 )

Concept of Separation of Powers .... by the Constitution's Supremacy Clause, under which .... and security, interstate and foreign commerce, and the .... necessary." Alexander Hamilton in The Federalist No. .... (10146 41 )

Category: Government - T
Common Topics
Click Here to Get Instant Access to over 32,000 Professionally Written Papers!!!
Join Now  
Saved Papers  
Save your essays here so you can locate them quickly!
"Thank you for making such a high quality site! Your papers are the best I have seen around"
Debbie B.
"Your site was very helpful and gave me the details I needed in order to complete my essay!!!"
Mike F.
"This site is an excellent vehicle for quick referrences. Thanks a bunch!"
Carla T.
"Great site, I got a lot of new ideas I would have never thought of before."
Nate A.
"I love this site!!!"
Marie H.
Copyright © 2007 - 2014 Lots of Essays. All Rights Reserved. DMCA