Differing Views of Karma

This study will examine and compare the different views of karma in Hinduism and Buddhism, including consideration of the Buddhist theory of dependent origination, the role of actions vs. intentions in karma, and the difference between the Hindu concept of reincarnation and the Buddhist concept of rebirth.

The concept of karma in general is not as simple as the popular interpretation of it would hold. Comparing the two religions' views brings out additional subtleties and complexities. On one level, karma would seem to lock the individual into a cycle of behavior from which he has no hope of breaking free, as Schroeder writes with respect to the Hindu definition of the concept:

Karma: "deed, action, impression": The law of causality: all events have causes and results; the principle of universal determinism applies to the mental and the moral sphere: our conditioning produces the impulse for every thought and action. Good/Evil acts have immediate psychological effects; good acts tend to break down our ego-centeredness and lead to liberation, while evil acts reinforce our ignorant assumption of the reality of the ego and inhibit our realization of all-inclusive consciousness.

Clearly, the Hindu concept of karma does give the individual freedom in choosing his actions, or such "liberation" through good acts would not be possible. The prison in which the ego entrap[s itself is composed of ignorance and ego, rather than a cycle from which the individual cannot break free.

Related Essays

Differing Conceptioins of Happiness .... These differing conceptions can be discerned in a comparison .... Different religions have different views of the idea of .... is opposed to the old conception of karma. .... (3993 16 )

Buddhist tradition .... an analogy to show the ingredients of Buddha's combined views of reincarnation and karma. .... is a flexible religion able to adapt to differing circumstances. .... (2957 12 )

The Nature of Buddhism .... an analogy to show the ingredients of Buddha's combined views of reincarnation and karma. .... is a flexible religion able to adapt to differing circumstances. .... (2880 12 )

Reduncy in Buddhist Tradition .... an analogy to show the ingredients of Buddha's combined views of reincarnation and karma. .... is a flexible religion able to adapt to differing circumstances. .... (2950 12 )

Concept of Karma & Reincarnation .... A differing view of karma is offered by Krishan .... found that when doctors understood patients' views of illness .... way in which reincarnation and karma are assisting .... (10009 40 )

rse is not based on a personal God, but rather on an indifferent force which strives at all times to maintain a balance or harmony between conflicting powers, which are rooted in the individual in relationship to the whole universe and its tendency to correct imbalances. The Buddhist concept of Dependent Origination, which is comprised of the twelve links of Conditioned Genesis, is a way to view the entire process of karma from a distance. The essence of the concept is that the origins of suffering are rooted in ignorance. Simply put, this means that the end of suffering will come with the awakening from ignorance. The cycle of karma can thereby be broken, and liberation attained. This process is long-term and complex because "the causes generated in one life cannot all be digested in their appropriate effects in the same life." The process involves a stopping or de-conditioning of numerous, interrelated elements of the karmic cycle, including the karma-foundations, the consciousness, the mind-and-body, the six sense-fields, impression, feeling, craving, grasping, becoming, birth, aging and dying, grief, sorrow, suffering, lamentation, and despair. The discouraging part of stopping the karmic cycle is that there are indeed so

Category: Philosophy - D