Two Concepts of the American Experience
This is an excerpt from the paper...
This paper compares and contrasts two ruminations on the American experience. The first, Louis Hartz's The Liberal Tradition in America, looks at the uniqueness of American history through the concept of the nation's liberal tradition, while the second, Eric Foner's The Story of American Freedom, examines the changing meanings of freedom throughout history. Both try to consider the uniqueness of the American experience through the prism of the word they have chosen as most useful to an examination of history. Both words are variations on the same approach, an attempt to consider American history by looking at one key concept that has shaped that history and been influenced by it. Louis Hartz first published The Liberal Tradition in America in 1955, during the heart of the Cold War. His exploration of the word "liberal" is, therefore, written during a time before its meaning had evolved into a more pejorative term. He is, in fact, using the word in one of its older senses, "the classic Lockian sense" (4), that of an openness to political, religious, and economic freedom. This was the general sense of the word when the nation was founded, before it became "clouded as it is by all sorts of modern social reform connotations" (4). "Liberal" has become something of a negative label, one that often accuses its followers of a sloppy disregard for social responsibility and tries to provide government solutions for situations that ought to instead be taken care of on an indivi
. . .
such a liberal perspective possible is the crux of Eric Foner's argument in The Story of American Freedom. In some respects, his perspective provides a focus and framework for Hartz's argument, making Foner's the broader conversation. Foner writes, "No idea is more fundamental to Americans' sense of themselves as individuals and as a nation than freedom" (xiii). Freedom made liberalism possible, allowed individuals the possibility of considering other points of view and other desires. Foner argues that freedom, more than any other quality, was the founding force behind the American political system and continues to mold the evolving state.
Foner sees freedom as the guiding impulse behind all stages of American history. He observes that the three most significant processes in the growth of America were "territorial expansion, political democratization, and the rapid spread of market relations" (48), all of which were powerfully affected by the idea of freedom and all of which influenced the ways in which freedom was looked at during this time. By the same token, the liberal tradition encouraged an expanding concept of freedom: "Changes in economic and religious life strongly encouraged the spread of a liberal understanding
. . .
Some common words found in the essay are:
American Freedom, Cold War, American Revolution, Tom Wicker, Hartz's Hartz, Hartz Foner, Thomas Jefferson, Roosevelt Theodore, Eric Foner, American Dream, liberal tradition, cold war, american political, american history, story american freedom, american freedom, story american, tradition america, american system, american experience, concept freedom, liberal tradition america, american political system, looking american history,
Approximate Word count = 2075
Approximate Pages = 8 (250 words per page)
More Essays on Two Concepts of the American Experience
|