Criminal Punishment & Deterrence Problem

The idea that harsh punishments are appropriately and even necessarily meted out to those found guilty of terrible crimes has a long history in societies throughout the world and is based on a number of ideas, including the concepts of revenge and deterrence.

The idea of deterrence is perhaps currently the more widely held of these beliefs as Gorecki (1979, p. 25) notes: "criminal punishment should be severe enough to arouse effective fear - either exactly severe enough or harsher than that."

However, while it might be obvious that a punishment as harsh as execution should deter criminals from committing acts punishable by death, this has not generally been found to be the case for a variety of possible reasons, as Nathanson (1987, pp. 17-19) argues:

The common sense argument that death is the best deterrent rests on the [false] belief that people fear death more than they fear anything elseÓ.

If the death penalty were properly administered and potential murders faced the certainty of their own deaths rather than a minimal risk of dying, then they would refrain from killing.

The problem with this objection is that we cannot guarantee that all murderers will be executed.

The second major argument in favor of the death penalty is simply its appropriateness to the crime at hand. That is the argument made in this paper, one summarized eloquently by the philosopher Immanuel Kant (cited in Zimring and Hawkins, 1973, p. 16):

Even if a Civil Society resolved to dissolve



Related Essays

Criminal adjudication the the role of punishment .... of future crime on the theory of deterrence and for .... a number of issues-facing the criminal justice system .... the volatile issue of capital punishment, for instance .... (1040 4 )

THE NATURE OF PUNISHMENT .... Deterrence is a reasonable objective for punishment, but deterrence has to be intended to help the criminal as well as to protect society. .... (3295 13 )

Capital Punishment Views .... maintain that ridding society of the criminal is as effective as any hope of deterrence.3 In .... has chosen to deal with capital punishment, ancient societies .... (2287 9 )

Issue of Capital Punishment .... advocates as really being interested in deterrence. .... and cruelty directed at the criminal, Bedau arrives .... unjust application of capital punishment and judicial .... (1773 7 )

Capital Punishment .... the crime is worth committing because of weak deterrence. .... never has to deal with the individual criminal or his .... So again capital punishment is viewed favorably .... (1202 5 )

Category: Government - C
Common Topics
Click Here to Get Instant Access to over 32,000 Professionally Written Papers!!!
Join Now  
Saved Papers  
Save your essays here so you can locate them quickly!
"This site is an excellent vehicle for quick referrences. Thanks a bunch!"
Carla T.
"Great site, I got a lot of new ideas I would have never thought of before."
Nate A.
"I love this site!!!"
Marie H.
"Thank you for making such a high quality site! Your papers are the best I have seen around"
Debbie B.
"Your site was very helpful and gave me the details I needed in order to complete my essay!!!"
Mike F.
Copyright © 2007 - 2014 Lots of Essays. All Rights Reserved. DMCA