The Davids of Michelangelo & Donatello

The differences in the two Davids stem, in part, from the fact that Donatello (1386-1466) was the premier sculptor of the first phase of the Florentine Renaissance, defined roughly as the period from 1400 to the mid-1440s, and, as such, was a pioneer in the introduction of classical style and concepts into contemporary art. Michelangelo (1475-1564), on the other hand, was a leading painter and architect as well as the dominant sculptor of the High Renaissance, a period that began around the turn of the sixteenth century, when "artists continued the most original trends of the fifteenth century, arriving at new solutions" to problems posed nearly a century ago (Adams 121). Other contrasts between the two Davids derive from variations in the conditions of their production. Donatello

. . .
Donatello's statue would seem inappropriate for an ordinary citizen, which Cosimo claimed to be, and would not have been ostentatiously displayed because "the commissioning of life-size bronze statues for a private palace could certainly invite the criticism of vainglory" (Gombrich 41). But such a work would also symbolize the growing culture of the family -- which was eager to disguise its unaristocratic roots -- because of its evocation of the classical past. The presentation of a major Biblical personage, and prefiguration of Christ, in a form that resembled "more Eros or Narcissus than the biblical hero" might show the learned classicism of the patron and the artist but it is also an artistic strategy that was very new at the time and might have proved offensive to many people (Godfrey 110). In addition, of course, the "iconographical ambiguity" of the statue extended to its homoerotic qualities (Becherucci 435). Donatello's presentation of David as a pretty young boy is clearly warranted by the description in 1 Samuel. He is shown entirely naked except for sandals and leggings that reach to his knees and a hat. He is, as Godfrey says, "a serenely pastoral boy with his long locks [and] garlanded shepherd's hat" (110).
. . .

Some common words found in the essay are:
Eros Narcissus, Guild Operai, Goliath David, Palazzo Vecchio, Donatello Padua, Unlike Biblical, Michelangelo's David, Giorgio Vasari, Hebrew Names, Donatello's David, donatello's statue, york icon-harper row, fortis manu, york icon-harper, homoerotic qualities, hartt 202, art york, humanist scholars, michelangelo chose, michelangelo's david, david's life, shown guise antique, cosimo de medici, 2nd ed york, ed york icon-harper,
Approximate Word count = 3363
Approximate Pages = 13 (250 words per page)

More Essays on The Davids of Michelangelo & Donatello