Argument Paper on Abortion as Morally Wrong

The topic of this presentation is that abortion is the killing of a human being, and it is morally wrong. Don Marquis, in his paper Why Abortion is Immoral sets about an eloquent argument that performing an abortion is in the same moral category as killing another human being (Marquis 183, 189-198, 201-202). He begins by explaining why he believes it is wrong to kill: first he says that it is wrong because it brutalizes the one who kills, and also that it deprives others of the individual's presence. However, he goes on to argue that these are not the major consequences of killing someone. The major consequences, he believes are that killing a person "deprives them of all the experiences, activities, projects, and enjoyments that would otherwise have constituted one's future" (Marquis 189-198) This, Marquis argues, makes killing wrong because the killing "inflicts one of the greatest possible losses on the victim" (Marquis 189-198).

What makes this worse, argues Marquis, is not that the victim is deprived of the activities, projects, experiences, and enjoyments of his future life which he enjoys now, but that there are also things which he may not enjoy now, but would have enjoyed in the future, and he is deprived of these, too (Marquis, 189-198). Killing, then, is wrong because it deprives an individual of their future.

Marquis points out that it is accepted that it is wrong to kill babies and young children because it is presumed they have future value (Marqui

Related Essays

Abortion and Morality .... is the killing of a human being, and it is morally wrong. Don Marquis, in his paper Why Abortion is Immoral sets about an eloquent argument that performing an .... (1508 6 )

Abortion as Unjustified .... is the killing of a human being, and it is morally wrong. Don Marquis, in his paper Why Abortion is Immoral sets about an eloquent argument that performing an .... (1507 6 )

Abortion and Killing .... is the killing of a human being, and it is morally wrong. Don Marquis, in his paper Why Abortion is Immoral sets about an eloquent argument that performing an .... (955 4 )

Abortions Are Immoral .... States and that is the subject of this paper. .... However, this argument is untenable for those who believe .... Most people who believe that abortion is morally wrong .... (1940 8 )

Right to Life .... the issue is so complex, this paper will confine .... Others, looking at the argument from a purely biological .... in the philosophical view that abortion is morally .... (1721 7 )

Category: Philosophy - A