The Miranda Decision

It was also one of the most politically controversial decisions in the history of the Court. For conservatives, and indeed for many ordinary Americans, it served to gel the notion that the courts, and particularly the Supreme Court under Chief Justice Earl Warren, were excessively lenient on criminal suspects and excessively restrictive of the police. It was frequently argued that the Court had "handcuffed the police" (Hickok, 1991, p. 297). Two years later, Richard Nixon was elected President. One of his stated goals was to appoint judges that would be "strict constructionists" of the Constitution -- meaning, most of all, that they would interpret the Bill of Rights in a more narrow and restrictive manner as applied to deviant or unpopular behavior, and most especially as applied to the rights of criminal suspects and defendants. The nomination of conse

. . .
n conservative enmity toward the Court, and the decision that conservatives most wanted to overturn. Roe v. Wade would have a profound impact in reshaping the Court debate a decade later, but in 1973 its primary impact still lay far in the future. Gradually, meanwhile, Miranda became accepted law and practice. As we have suggested above, it became a standard fixture of TV crime dramas, giving the final arrest of the villain a greater dramatic weight than the old, brief "book 'em." Politically, it became part of the regular litany of liberal Supreme Court decisions that were alleged to have "handcuffed" the police. A broad spectrum of Americans became, and remain, convinced that the courts "coddle criminals." This writer has heard that specific phrase more than once, in casual conversation with friends and family members, sometimes uttered by individuals who are by no means conservative in their overall views. Miranda is by no means the only element in this perception. Few people could identify the Miranda decision by name, though most would probably recognize the "Miranda warning" because of its frequent use by Hollywood. The perception of overly lenient courts has been fed not only by Miranda and other decisions restrict
. . .

Some common words found in the essay are:
Supreme Court, Warren Court's, Roe Wade, Rehnquist Court, Earl Warren, Clarence Thomas, Justice Rehnquist, Richard Nixon, Dirty Harry, Oreste Fulminante, supreme court, chief justice, roe wade, criminal suspects, court decisions, miranda decision, miranda warning, bork nomination, rights criminal suspects, exception miranda, warren court, court chief justice, supreme court chief, police hickok 1991, miranda decision handed,
Approximate Word count = 5090
Approximate Pages = 20 (250 words per page)