Hemingway's Soldier's Home

Someone once said that war talk by those who have never been to war is dull. In other words, those who have been through a war are totally changed and harmed in such a way that they can never share it with anyone who has not been to war. In a way, this accurately characterizes the dilemma of Harold Krebs, the protagonist in Ernest Hemingway's short story of a man returning from combat Soldier's Home (1925). Within Soldier's Home, it can be shown that Harold cannot fulfill the "glorious" visions of war held by those in his hometown. He found nothing "glorious" about combat and cannot play the role others in his town cast for him (Hemingway http://www.cis.vt.edu/modernworld/d/hemingway.html#3). Bernardo defines Harold's dilemma when she discusses a common trait of the Hemingway hero, "A person who believes in nothing requires tremendous courage just to keep on living, but for the Hemingway hero it is better than living a lie" (Bernardo 1). This paper will demonstrate how Hemingway's belief that it is better to believe in "nothing" than to live a lie is illustrated in Harold's inability to reenter society after the war.

Harold Krebs returns to his boyhood home and finds nothing has changed. People still park where they did before he left and the girls look just like the girls he remembered before leaving. Other returning veterans have adjusted to small-town life. Harold cannot adjust. For though nothing in the town has changed, the experiences in co

Related Essays

A Soldier's Home .... Bernardo, K. Ernest Hemingway's Soldier's Home. .... Lamb, Robert PaulThe love song of Harold Krebs: Form, argument, and meaning in Hemingway's Soldier's Home. .... (940 4 )

Comparison of Hemingway's Fiction With His Life There are numerous .... Hemingway, Ernest. "Soldier's Home." The Complete Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway: The Finca Vigia Edition. .... 1986. Lynn, Kenneth S. Hemingway. .... (2352 9 )

Relation Between Hemingway's Life & Fiction .... Hemingway, Ernest. "Soldier's Home." The Complete Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway: The Finca Vigia Edition. .... 1986. Lynn, Kenneth S. Hemingway. .... (2345 9 )

Ernest Hemingway .... Maria's multiple rapes was an oft-told tale of fascist control of villages that Hemingway had learned from a soldier whose nurse .... Lynn, Kenenth S. Hemingway. .... (1387 6 )

Hemingway & World War I .... For Hemingway's ex-soldier, the war signifies a confrontation .... The genius of Hemingway, we might suggest, lies in .... presented are colored by the mood(s) of Nick .... (3189 13 )

Category: Literature - H