In Plato's Republic, the philosophical question of justice arises between Socrates and Glaucon.1 Glaucon suggests three categories of justice and posits that justice is just a manmade convention that humans practice because it is to their advantage to do so. He and Socrates come to an agreement that that justice is both good in itself as well as for the good that comes out of it, included in the category in which "the man who is going to be blessed should like both for itself and for what comes out of it" (358a). However, they differ on whether justice produces happiness merely because it is inherently good or because it produces corollary benefits. Glaucon believes that people only practice justice when it serves them and produces consequences that they like; everyone would be just if justice benefited them, he feels, but if it didn't they would not act justly. Plato's own belief is that justice is more than just a human convention; it has an absolute reality of goodness of its own and should be pursued even if the consequences are not personally advantageous. The difference between these two views is characterized by a concomitant difference in vantage point; Glaucon sees the issue from the perspective of personal gain or loss, while Plato sees it from outside that realm in the sphere of absolute truths. Clearly, an absolute truth is more viable and defensible than a personal interest, and that is what this paper will prove: that justice is a higher order than perso
Related Essays
Plato's Definition of Justice.... consisted of minding one;s own business while today we believe that justice is minding everyone else's business while they mind ours. Plato. The Republic. .... (1288 5 )
Plato's Theory of Justice.... consisted of minding one-s own business while today we believe that justice is minding everyone else's business while they mind ours. Plato. The Republic. .... (1292 5 )
Concept of Justice.... He points to the fact that Bob Dole and others define justice in terms .... Grube, GMA Plato Republic. .... McElvaine, Robert S. "To Do or Not to Do--That is the Question .... (1770 7 )
The Augustinian State.... yet informed by pre-Christian commentaries, particularly Plato and Aristotle .... no right where there is no justice, then most .... it fol lows that there s no republic .... (1862 7 )
Socrates The Apology.... Just as wisdom is bound up with justice in Plato's .... might seem to be consistent with Plato's idea that .... of the successful exercise of reason: "[S]omething than .... (4497 18 )
Polybius' View of a Mixed Constitional Government.... [I]f we imagine the State in process of creation, we shall see the justice and injustice of the State .... Plato. The Republic. .... Translated by Evelyn S. Shockburgh. .... (1879 8 )
5 
)
= 999
= 4 (250 words per page)
