Machiavelli on Leadership

In delineating different requirements of leadership for different kinds of states, Niccolo Machiavelli, in The Prince, is concerned only with the maintenance of power, rather than with any ethical consideration. Whatever rationalization is made in defending Machiavelli's ideas, the fact remains that those ideas are rooted in the worship of power. Machiavelli, based on the ideas in this book, would have honored Hitler, Franklin Roosevelt, and Stalin equally, because they were able to maintain power, though in different ways. Machiavellian ideas are at work in democracies as well as in tyrannies, for Machiavelli does not simply advocate brute force as the only or primary tool of the leader, but instead argues for persuasion---including the use of any necessary lies---if persuasion works. In any case, as Machiavelli notes, if the leaders "depend on their own energies and can make use of force, then they hardly ever come to grief" (17). His ideas can be used as intellectual justification not only for the brutality of tyrannies, but for much of the corruption and deception which are today so blatantly a part of the democratic process as well.

As for the acquisition of power. Machiavelli advocates the swift ruthlessness later used by Hitler, Stalin and other brutal tyrants: "He should calculate the sum of all the injuries he will have to do, and do them all at once" (27).

Again, whatever Machiavelli's practical aim in writing this book, with respect to restoring order to his o

Related Essays

Machiavelli's use of Moses in The Prince .... that Moses does indeed have open communications with God, or with the voice of the force which Machiavelli considers the source of good leadership, whether it .... (833 3 )

MOSES AND MACHIAVELLI .... leader aiming high. Machiavelli uses the term virtu, a certain range of aiming high, of political and leadership skills. He uses the .... (1012 4 )

Machiavelli and Charlemagne .... Charlemagne is Machiavelli's theory of ideal leadership come to life, or as close to the ideal as one may reasonably expect. The .... (1419 6 )

Machiavelli: His political ideas .... No country or government lasts for-ever without revolution or without major changes in government and leadership, but Machiavelli does not seem to recognize .... (2219 9 )

Sucessful Leadership Qualities in the Military .... Ledeen, Michael. Machiavelli on Modern Leadership. New York: Luvaas, Jay. "Napoleon and the Art of Command." The Challenge of Military Leadership, Eds. .... (2199 9 )

The fact that he is writing to Roman leaders in praise of their government and leadership does not discount the fact that he is grants more power and wisdom to the people than he would later even consider in The Prince, a work in which he has nothing but pure contempt for the people. It also does not seem believable that he had simply changed his mind about the people by the time he wrote The Prince. It seems more likely that Machiavelli simply disguised his true feelings and later exposed them when he felt safe. Can we believe that a man who espouses the view that "The voice of the people is the voice of God" (109) and sees them in a later work as nothing more than obstacles to the prince's exercise of power. Later in the Discourses, Machiavelli begins to show the cynical contempt for humanity which will burst force in The Prince. In that passage, he writes that "cunning and deceit will serve a man better than force to rise from a base condition to great fortune" (112). This liking for cunning and deceit is what would mark Machiavelli's later work, The Prince. J.R. Hale, in assessing The Prince, sees it as the result of a natural evolution in Machiavelli's thinking from the time of the Discourses. Still, Hale recognizes impor

Category: Philosophy - M