Max Weber's Views of Religious Traditions

Max Weber interprets rational action not in terms of individual actors but rather in terms of macrostructure and social order. In Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Weber develops the argument that society itself is the result of successive application of rational action in the context of and a shared experience of community order and stability that enable social processes and organization to occur.

According to Weber, the origins and development of various religious traditions in the creative human enterprise are relevant to the rationalization of social order. Whatever opinion one has of religion is irrelevant to the evidence that the religious response to found experience has to do with the deliberate attempts to make the cosmos increasingly thinkable. Religious consciousness, says Weber, is a method of organizing, or regulating, experience. In Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Weber stresses the rationalization dynamics that went to work after the Reformation, as the Protestant ethic of material enterprise and a life of work (or "life's work") spread throughout Europe to counter the Catholic ethic of doctrinal authority and preoccupation with matters spiritual. Indeed, he locates the dynamic in the personality and career of Luther and Calvin. In a broad sense Protestantism as a counter to Catholic otherworldliness made a project of finding an ethical theory of the material world. As Weber puts it:

Protestants (especially certain branches of the

Related Essays

Durkhein and Weber on Religion .... He views society as the sum total of various forces .... most solipsistic individuals ineluctably move toward social reintegration: "[S]ocial progress .... Weber, ..... .... (1803 7 )

Society and Religion in Non-Western Societies .... (S)ome elements of a region-wide heritage are .... Max Weber likens Taoism to heterodoxy in contrast to the .... Davis suggests that recent versions of Weber's theory of .... (4410 18 )

Society and Religion in Non-Western Societies .... (S)ome elements of a region-wide heritage are .... Max Weber likens Taoism to heterodoxy in contrast to the .... Davis suggests that recent versions of Weber's theory of .... (6222 25 )

Weber's Sociology of Law .... on a given issue irrational and their own views rational. .... Willie Cravin calls DA's case 'weak' and says glove demonstration .... From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology .... (5964 24 )

Economic Theories .......... -- iol .... Views by social historians and sociologists are more .... ooerate or, a I.arop- S.@onomic scale .... Max Weber investigated relationships between Protestant ethic and .... (4333 17 )

Human Behavior and Sociology .... major contributors to this theory Were Max Weber and George .... the philosophical belief that all views are equally .... people expect them to behave (Elwell,'s, 1998). .... (5766 23 )

ible hand" of market order and rationality held to be a feature of capitalism. In a footnote Weber (213) also quotes Smith's explanation of general acquiescence in capitalism in terms of "self-love," or the benefits derived by rational participants who exchange what they have of value in the capitalist marketplace. These are not sexual or psychological but material benefits. For the relationship between rational action and self-interest involves formulating the compulsions of individuals in economic rather than spiritual terms, i.e., in terms of cost and benefit instead of good and evil. It is important to recognize that Weber's approach to his topic is systematic to the point of being scientific. Despite the religious subject matter, Weber does not resort to polemical or moralistic rhetoric, except in so far as he valorizes and universalizes the concept of rationalism, or rationalization, that invisible force, process, and attitude whereby a society evolves away from a world explained by superstition, magic, and emotion toward social structure and organization that can be controlled (or, at any rate, explained). That does not mean that a rational attitude guarantees a perfectly reasonable and just social structure, still less ra

Category: Philosophy - M