Love Is A Fallacy

Max Shulman's short story Love Is A Fallacy recounts the efforts of a college student to educate his love interest, Polly, so she can be a fit wife, hostess, and mother. The education of Polly involves explaining the most common types of fallacies: Dicto Simpliciter, Hasty Generalization, Post Hoc, Contradictory Premises, Ad Misericordiam, False Analogy, Hypothesis Contrary to Fact, and Poisoning the Well. These fallacies demonstrate an improper use of reasoning, but the narrator discovers Polly turns from his Galatea to his Monster by using his logic lessons against his pleas for love. The fallacy that is most interesting in the story is the one known as Hypothesis Contrary to Fact, which demonstrates how guilty the narrator is of misusing logic to win Polly. Examples from Love Is A Fallacy will be used to demonstrate this.

The narrator tells us of his five evenings spent teaching Polly the most common logic fallacies. Seated under an oak at the college "trysting place" known as the Knoll, the narrator instructs Polly in the different types fallacies by providing her with concrete examples of each (Shulman 5). Slowly and painstakingly, the narrator attempts to educate Polly by sharing with her what he has learned from his logic class. Polly's lack of intelligence causes the narrator to wince, hide his exasperation, fight off despair, grind his teeth, chuckle with amusement, and pushes him to the limits of "what



Related Essays

False Dilemma Fallacy .... The false dilemma fallacy is also known as the "either-or" fallacy because it .... For instance, there is a saying, "America, love it or leave it" which suggests .... (286 1 )

DH Lawrence's Critique of Whitman .... not quite know that to do with the idea of an "epoch to establish the love of comrades .... One fallacy is that everyone has to follow Christian thought and behavior .... (1080 4 )

Logical Fallacies in Advertising .... It's been said that advertisers love short cuts -- particularly those which .... ADVERTISEMENT J: CLEARSIGHT Type of Fallacy: TRANSFER/EUPHEMISM Source: THE WHOLE .... (1465 6 )

Appeal to Pity .... a widow named Missy Johnson, and commented that "you know, it's hard work to try to love her as .... Another commonly used fallacy is known as the Bandwagon Fallacy .... (1041 4 )

Women in Military Combat .... A fallacy of relevance embedded in this argument is that it makes an indirect appeal to the reader's desire for security, love, and other social goods in order .... (1397 6 )

Category: Literature - L
Common Topics
Click Here to Get Instant Access to over 32,000 Professionally Written Papers!!!
Join Now  
Saved Papers  
Save your essays here so you can locate them quickly!
"Great site, I got a lot of new ideas I would have never thought of before."
Nate A.
"I love this site!!!"
Marie H.
"Thank you for making such a high quality site! Your papers are the best I have seen around"
Debbie B.
"Your site was very helpful and gave me the details I needed in order to complete my essay!!!"
Mike F.
"This site is an excellent vehicle for quick referrences. Thanks a bunch!"
Carla T.
Copyright © 2007 - 2014 Lots of Essays. All Rights Reserved. DMCA