Stranger With A Camera

Elizabeth Barret's documentary about a murder of another documentary filmmaker that occurred in eastern Kentucky in 1960 reveals the dilemma of journalists (outsiders) who try to chronicle the existence from the point-of-view of those living it (insiders). As Barret herself asks, "What are the responsibilities of any of us who take images of other people and put them to our own uses?" Yet, if we look at this documentary closely, we see many other issues that are intellectually and disturbing from an ethical point-of-view. For example, the film purports that the poor, uneducated, dirty, toothless Appalachians we are used to in mainstream media portrayals are only some Appalachians. Because of this negative media portrayal, the filmmaker contends that the natives of these regions withdrew into themselves and their communities, with everyone else representing an "outsider" who was merely trying to label all Appalachians poor, uneducated, toothless, and dirty.

Therefore, according to the filmmaker, when promising young Canadian filmmaker Hugh O'Connor came to town in order to chronicle the "insiders", he was setting himself up as an unwelcome "outsider". In fact, claims Barret, O'Connor was not trying to show the poor, uneducated plight of Appalachians, but was instead trying to show how there are similarities in human culture that beyond demographic and geographic lines. Therefore, a more disturbing issue in this film t

Related Essays

My Darling Clementine .... Ford allows the camera to hold on the faces of his actors (without taking .... squinting eyes clearly show a dangerous man sizing up the stranger passing through .... (1378 6 )

Blue Velvet .... Vallens, since she is exposed to him more than she normally would be to a stranger. .... The camera shows us just enough of her naked form for us to know she is .... (1021 4 )

Workplace Violence as a Major Security Concern .... Because stranger violence is considered an external threat (eg, street crime), this paper .... device that converts any personal computer with a video camera into a .... (2343 9 )

The Crowd & The Grapes of Wrath .... The camera then slowly pulls back to reveal the crowd of which these two .... the withholding of simple human courtesy such as one might expect from any stranger. .... (1646 7 )

Films Critiquing Social Scene of Their Era .... The camera then slowly pulls back to reveal the crowd of which these two .... the withholding of simple human courtesy such as one might expect from any stranger. .... (1667 7 )

Category: Literature - S