Small is Beautiful by E. F. Schumacher
This is an excerpt from the paper...
In his book, Small is Beautiful, E. F. Schumacher sets forth the idea that land is sacred, and the use of land is not to be confused with the use of labor and capital, the other factors of production as accepted by economists. Schumacher suggests that land has three tasks: to keep man in touch with living nature; to humanize and ennoble man's wider habitat; and to bring forth the foodstuff and other materials necessary to maintain life. This research explores Schumacher's views regarding land, and compares them with Milton Friedman, Mich'l Parenti and the views expressed in Worker Empowerment, a series of essays edited by Jon Wisman.Schumacher defines land as including not only the soil, but also the living things (plants and animals taken together), human beings, water and air which combined make up nature. Land is not made by man and once its properties are destroyed through clear cutting, over cultivation, overgrazing or other means, it is not easily renewable. There is a finite supply of land; additional land cannot be created. Schumacher suggests that civilizations have fallen because of land mismanagement, a fact which he laments is lost on many historians. Schumacher finds that human beings have an obligation to the land and the animals on the land which is nothing less than noblesse oblige. Adam and Eve were given dominion over the earth to "dress it and keep it," not to tyrannize it. To this end, Schumacher calls for the ethical treatment of animals us
. . .
bling to Schumacher, is the idea that agriculture for Mansholt is just another "industry." It is subject to the same measurements and analysis as any industry, with the same pressure to produce short-term results. This view of agriculture is, to Schumacher, fundamentally flawed. Agriculture is unique because land is unique and not subject to the same analysis as are other factors of production. Until analysts are able to make that distinction and use their talents to view agriculture as an entity fundamentally different from industry, the same mistakes regarding land management, including the exploitation and destruction of land, will continue to occur.
In his essay, "Against All Odds: The Struggle for Workplace Democracy in the Third World," Mieke Meurs supports Schumacher's idea that land and land use provides a unique opportunity for economic and social prosperity. According to Meurs, farming cooperatives which have been tried in developing countries produce economic and social benefits which are not otherwise realized in these economies. Problems occur when central bureaucracies attempt to impose central planning on these cooperatives. The goals of the central planners can be at odds with the goals and objectives
. . .
Some common words found in the essay are:
Indeed Schumacher, According Meurs, War II, Schumacher Mansholt, Bank America, Unlike Schumacher, Mich'l Parenti, Wisman Schumacher, Friedmans Schumacher, Beautiful Schumacher, land management, factor production, industrial revolution, according schumacher, struggle workplace democracy, third world, struggle workplace, land land, land factor, farming cooperatives, workplace democracy, land factor production, schumacher considers land, short-term profits long-term, merely factor production,
Approximate Word count = 2527
Approximate Pages = 10 (250 words per page)
|