Bilingual education in American Schools

This paper is a critical examination of the issue of bilingual education in American schools. Diane Ravitch, an educator and scholar with experience in the field, argues that efforts to teach children in two languages, their language of origin and English, have failed, and that structured immersion, in which students are taught exclusively in English, is the only really effective way to keep students advancing and achieving in school.

She bases her argument on the rates for Hispanic students "unable to pass an English-language test after three years of bilingual education" (Ravitch, 1997, p. 94). Ravitch further notes that students unable to develop fluency in English are more likely to fail in life, since "unless students are fluent in English, they will not have a fair chance of graduating from high school, going to college, and getting good jobs" (1997, p. 95). She has a good point. However, her insistence on the abolition of bilingual education as a solution is shortsighted and ignores the considerable research that has led to the establishment of an extensive nationwide program of bilingual education.

Until the early 1960s, public education in the United States consisted of a more ignorant version of Ravitch's approach. Schools used a "sink or swim" policy for students who could not speak English, holding them back until they had mastered English and conducting instruction exclusively in English, regardless of the child's language of origin (Baker, 1981).

Related Essays

Bilingual Education in American Schools This paper is a critical examination of the issue of bilingual education in American schools. Diane Ravitch, an educator and scholar .... (825 3 )

Theoretical Concepts and BiLingual Education .... the soundness of the pedagogical premises of bilingual education, the actual implementation of bilingual education programs in American public schools has not .... (4595 18 )

Bilingual Education Issues .... dilapidated, under-funded public schools go without .... reason many people oppose bilingual education is because .... that is characteristic of American society and .... (1979 8 )

BILINGUAL EDUCATION IN CALIFORNIA .... of his and his family's American dream. BILINGUAL EDUCATION HISTORY. Bilingual education has been used in 80 percent of today's public schools, especially in .... (2867 11 )

Issues of Bilingual Education .... in which bilingual education has emerged in the American political and .... which was meant to dismantle and block bilingual education in public schools, was (or .... (2527 10 )

Category: Psychology - B