Adam Smith and Karl Marx: The Division of Labor

 
 
 
 
Adam Smith and Karl Marx: The Division of Labor

Adam Smith and Karl Marx, despite the radical difference of their opinions on capitalism, were two of the greatest economic analysts of their eras. In general, Smith (1974) takes the position that the division of labor that occurred concomitantly with the Industrial Revolution has the effect of increasing wealth for a society as a whole and expanding the opportunities for meaningful employment for workers. Marx (2002), on the other hand, argues that the evolution of modern industry and the division of labor subjects workers to oppressive, dehumanizing working conditions while concentrating wealth in the hands of a few. This brief analysis will assess each argument. While Marx (2002) makes a valid point regarding the impact of capitalism and industrialism on workers, it is Smith's (1974) discussion of the division of labor that is most convincing.

Smith (1974, p. 109) opens his discussion by stating that "the greatest improvements in the productive powers of laborÓ seem to have been the effects of the division of labor." In the great manufacturing centers that were developed during the early years of the Industrial Revolution, Smith (1974, p. 109) saw opportunities for employment of "so great a number of workmen that it is impossible to collect them all into the same workhouse." Industrialization, said Smith (1974, p. 112), fostered a "great increase of the quantity of work which, in consequence of the division of

     
 
 
 
    

 

Related Essays

Marx, Smith & Weber on Division of Labor .... To social theorists, such as Karl Marx, Adam Smith and Max Weber, the division of labor is more than economics; it is rooted in their own individual philosophy .... (1157 5 )

Division of labor .... To social theorists, such as Karl Marx, Adam Smith and Max Weber, the division of labor is more than economics; it is rooted in their own individual philosophy .... (1157 5 )

Marx & Adam Smith .... He did not see, as Marx did, that the division of labor had serious implications for labor, the greatest of which .... Works Cited Marx, Karl. "The F Smith, Adam. .... (1333 5 )

ADAM SMITH AND THE NEW ORDER OF INDUSTRIAL CAPITALISM .... Competition, self-interest, division of labor- all of these are .... Work Cited: Smith, Adam. .... KEYNES AND MARX Karl Marx and John Maynard Keynes each made their .... (2275 9 )

Adam Smith on Wages .... WORKS CITED "Adam Smith." Biographies. .... http://www.bluepete.com/Literature/Biographies/ Philosophy/Smith.htm Barber, WJ A History of Economic Thought .... Marx, Karl. .... (4223 17 )


Category: Philosophy - A
 
 
 
Common Topics
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Click Here to Get Instant Access to over 32,000 Professionally Written Papers!!!
 
 
 
Join Now  
 
 
 
 
 
Saved Papers  
 
 
Save your essays here so you can locate them quickly!
 
 
 
Testimonials  
 
"Your site was very helpful and gave me the details I needed in order to complete my essay!!!"
Mike F.
 
"This site is an excellent vehicle for quick referrences. Thanks a bunch!"
Carla T.
 
"Great site, I got a lot of new ideas I would have never thought of before."
Nate A.
 
"I love this site!!!"
Marie H.
 
"Thank you for making such a high quality site! Your papers are the best I have seen around"
Debbie B.
 
 
 
 
Copyright © 2007 - 2014 Lots of Essays. All Rights Reserved. DMCA