Religious melancholia

This paper explores the topic of religious melancholia as a culture-bound illness in which one feels forsaken by God. It next examines writings by W. E. B. DuBois for evidence that he suffered from this condition. Finally, it examines DuBois' concept of "double consciousness," in order to present an argument that it arose from his psychological state of religious melancholia.

Religious melancholy is explored in depth by Rubin. In his Preface, Rubin explains and defines religious melancholia as follows:

Melancholy here refers to an affect, a distinctive stance toward life, a grieving over the loss of God's love, and an obsession and psychopathology associated with the spiritual itinerary of conversion. The religious melancholiac desired, above all, else, to foster . . . an inward devotional life marked by a warm, personal relationship with God. Yet, those who would know God in moments of rapture and contemplation so frequently found themselves forsaken by God (vii).

Rubin goes on to explain that he had encountered cases of religious melancholia during his doctoral research in sociology, when he read the records and correspondence of mental patients during the era of the religious revival called the Second Great Awakening, in 1820s to 1840s. His investigation of this phenomenon led him to realize that the concept of religious melancholia, first coined by Robert Burton in The Anatomy of Melancholy (1621), had been "commonplace among Americans but by the early twentieth

Related Essays

Integration of Theology & Psychology .... perfect" (Rom 12:2). To accept the anti-religious fulminations of .... creeping insanity of modern living, the desolation, isolation, melancholia, and depression .... (3725 15 )

Hamlet & Social Psych... .... and wrestles with depression and deep bouts of melancholia balanced by .... He believed that religious statistics coupled with suicide statistics proved that the .... (2570 10 )

Romantic Neoclassic .... idealism; a paradoxical tendency toward both free though and religious mysticism; revolt .... in this poem, even painful ones and the focus on melancholia which was .... (1450 6 )

The Collective Unconscious .... This phenomenon is also substantiated through religious experience and quantum physics .... Freud pointed out that mourning was different from melancholia, a case in .... (5615 22 )

Sophocles, Plato, Marcus Aurelius, and Andraeus Capellanus .... that they all suffered from what was classically called melancholia or is now .... aand of what relationships it may have had to heretical religious movements is .... (2713 11 )

A person in severe depression may be completely immobilized by it. incapable of attending to any of life's necessities. A slightly less depressed person may be a "ball of fire," since incessant activity, especially if the activity is felt to be inherently significant, can serve as a bulwark against descent into a deeper depression. Persons suffering from this degree of depression thus often evolve distinctive life strategies for coping with their condition, and this would explain the drivenness and amazing productivity of a William James or a W. E. B. DuBois. Before attention is directed onto DuBois, one might comment that Rubin's excellent study stops short of dealing with an important modern approach to the phenomenon of religious melancholia, in that he does not touch upon Jung or the "Twelve-Step" movement (although this is understandable, in that analysis of that movement would require a book in itself). Rubin does mention Christian inspirational literature (227), but does not place it in the much broader context of "recovery literature." Suffice it to say here that Bill Wilson's founding of Alcoholics Anonymous was facilitated by a remark by Jung that only a religious conversion could "cure" severe alcoholism. W. E.

Category: Psychology - R