Mill & Marx on Freedom
This is an excerpt from the paper...
Both John Stuart Mill and Karl Marx were philosophers with a strong emphasis on individual freedom. Mill viewed freedom under a legitimate government concerned with the greatest good as necessary and possible. Mill (93) argued in On Liberty that individual freedom is and must be viewed as a ôsacrosanctö quality, and that there are few if any circumstances under which a state may rightfully interfere with individual freedom. Karl Marx also theorized about societyÆs evolution toward true freedom, believing society evolved toward freedom in historical stages. He viewed capitalism as a necessary stage toward evolution of true freedom, one that was required to bring about through alienation of labor a revolution that would shift the means of production and create a communist society. As Sullivan (1) suggests, ôMarx was concerned ultimately with human freedom, reviving the ancient concept of communism, wherein human beings could fulfill their cooperative roles within society without fear of exploitation.ö This analysis will provide a discussion of MillÆs liberal view of individual freedom and MarxÆ social class and economic view of individual freedom. A conclusion will discuss whether or not Karl MarxÆ analysis successfully counters and provides an adequate and convincing alternative to John MillÆs much more liberal understanding of freedom.John Stuart MillÆs liberal philosophy of personal or individual freedom stems from hi
. . .
ined that ôIt is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but, on the contrary, their social being that determines their consciousnessö (Sullivan 1).
In other words, Marx believed that social infrastructure, capitalism in our contemporary world, imparts beliefs and values. In this way, history is a ôclass struggleö to Marx, one wherein one group has advantage over the other in ways that oppress individual freedom: ôfreeman and slave, patrician and plebian, lord and serfàin a word, oppressor and oppressed,ö (Rayment, p. 1). Different classes form and maintain values and beliefs that typically favor their own class and oppress the liberties or freedoms of other classes. We can see this in Hindu society or even modern America, where the values and beliefs of white, wealth Protestants still dominate through social institutions. As Marx believed, ôThe entire class creates and forms them out of its material foundations and out of the corresponding social relations,ö (Sabine and Thorston, p. 696). In this view, there is no consideration of the greatest happiness for the greatest number or the utility promoted by MillÆs liberal view of individual freedom.
Marx saw little of the natural harmony proposed of capital
. . .
Some common words found in the essay are:
Soviet Union, Manifesto Marx, Stuart MillÆs, Karl Marx, Saddam Hussein, Mill Marx, Nations Marx, Communist Manifesto, Viewed Jul, Despite MillÆs, individual freedom, millÆs liberal, means production, true freedom, liberal view, millÆs liberal view, evolution true, john stuart, rayment 1, sullivan 1, evolution true freedom, view individual freedom, successfully counters, jul 22 2005, owners means production,
Approximate Word count = 1970
Approximate Pages = 8 (250 words per page)
More Essays on Mill & Marx on Freedom
|
Customer Service
to Over
32,000 Professionally Written Papers!!!
