What is 'Educated?' History and Education: The Case of Columbus

As James W. Loewen pointed out, there is a great deal wrong with the way that American history textbooks have traditionally presented history (332). Loewen also makes the case that many teachers of American history have failed to incorporate multiple perspectives on major events and issues thereby cheating their students of opportunities to gain an in-depth understanding of the forces, people, and situations that have impacted upon their world (352).

Building on this concept, this essay looks specifically at the case of Christopher Columbus, certainly one of the most widely known and largely misunderstood figures involved in the post-Conquest of the Americas. Drawing upon two scholarly studies focused on Columbus, his accomplishments, and his significance in terms of American history and the way it has been taught, this essay will expand the conversation about history and education begun earlier in this series of reports. The thesis to be discussed herein is that the case of Columbus as a subject for historical scholarship reveals a longstanding tradition of interpreting Columbus and his actions from a Eurocentric perspective only - a perspective that is now being challenged by many scholars.

John P. Larner is one scholar who has studied the aggrandizement of Columbus in American history texts and scholarship. Larner takes the position that what has been constructed over time is a "dramatic image" of Columbus that incorporates "hero worship, myth, its interac

Related Essays

California Indians and Public Education During .... right for their children to be educated alongside whites .... complete a high school education in California .... History, literature, music, art, cooking, and sewing, in .... (2544 10 )

Howard Zinn's American History .... conditions because there are no such instances in history. .... Women were educated to accept this system, so .... kept ignorant, given only the education they needed to .... (3587 14 )

Chicano Movement Journal .... administrators, and staff should be educated; they should .... that only focuses on white history and experience .... these needs were included: Education, Housing, Health .... (2592 10 )

Journal on Chicano Issues .... administrators, and staff should be educated; they should .... that only focuses on white history and experience .... these needs were included: Education, Housing, Health .... (2592 10 )

Mobility of Women in Middle Management .... Woman's Proper lace: A History of Changing Ideals and .... the secretary of the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare .... than do younger and less-educated blacks .... (8091 32 )

Category: History - W