Hypothetical Supreme Court Case Study

Page Count: 12
Length: 2983 Words

The purpose of this research is to examine a hypothetical Supreme Court case study, Mayor of New York v. YIPES. The plan of the research will be to set forth the facts of the case in light of constitutional law and politics, and to refer to relevant precedents in deciding the question whether the Yale Interplanetary Peace Emergency Security Act (YIPES) is constitutional.

We may safely dispose of one ancillary question immediately, which is that in no case may an elected Congress and the president interpret the Constitution differently than the Supreme Court, the Court should comply with their view. This notion does violence to the entire conception of judicial review, first articulated in Marbury v. Madison and reinforced by a tradition that has standing not least on account of Article III's declaration that "judicial Power shall extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity, arising under this Constitution" (O'Brien 11, 33).

In this case, what we find is that executive and legislative power have been inappropriately extended to interfere with Law and Equity in direct challenge to judicial power specifically and programmatically set forth in Article III. Indeed, this case has been complicated not least by executive and legislative authorities' conflation of civil and criminal domains at both municipal and federal level. Criminal-law jurisdiction has been asserted (or abdicated) for reasons of civil law, while civil-law jurisdiction has been asserted as the basis for matters of cri

Read the full essay by joining our writing community – over 32,000 professional essays and term papers. Access this essay now!

Category: Government - H

Some common topics found in the essays are:

York City, Klingon Nogaine, York Jersey, Article II, III Indeed, York City's, City South, YIPES Congress, Amendment XIV, NYPD Mayor's, york city, due process, government entities, resident aliens, constitutional law, nogaine resident, executive legislative, federal government, constitutional law politics, amendment xiv, york city's, nogaine resident aliens, law politics 3rd, ed 2 vols, politics 3rd ed,

Click Here to Get Instant Access to over 32,000 Professionally Written Papers!!!